Is Hell Forever? Dante, Plato, and What the Hebrew Scriptures Really Say
For centuries preachers have held up a picture of fire that burns forever, souls screaming without end, and a Creator who keeps them alive to suffer. Cry aloud and spare not: that picture did not come from Moses or the prophets. It came from Greek myth, from Plato, and from a medieval Italian poem. The Hebrew Scriptures teach something else.
What the Hebrew Scriptures say about the dead
“For the living know that they shall die; but the dead know not any thing, neither have they any more a reward; for the memory of them is forgotten.”
Ecclesiastes 9:5, JPS 1917
“Whatsoever thy hand attaineth to do by thy strength, that do; for there is no work, nor device, nor knowledge, nor wisdom, in the grave, whither thou goest.”
Ecclesiastes 9:10, JPS 1917
“His breath goeth forth, he returneth to his dust; In that very day his thoughts perish.”
Psalm 146:4, JPS 1917
“For in death there is no remembrance of Thee; In the nether-world who will give Thee thanks?”
Psalm 6:6, JPS 1917
The word translated “the grave” and “the nether-world” is Sheol. It is the grave, the place of the dead, where good and evil alike go down. Jacob expected to go down to Sheol (Genesis 37:35). It is not a torture chamber. The sentence on man was plain from the start:
“…for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.”
Genesis 3:19, JPS 1917
“Behold, all souls are Mine; as the soul of the father, so also the soul of the son is Mine; the soul that sinneth, it shall die.”
Ezekiel 18:4, JPS 1917
The soul that sins dies. It is not kept alive forever to burn. The soul is not immortal. Only the Eternal is.
The end of the wicked: ashes
“For, behold, the day cometh, It burneth as a furnace; and all the proud, and all that work wickedness, shall be stubble; and the day that cometh shall set them ablaze, Saith YHVH of hosts, that it shall leave them neither root nor branch.”
Malachi 3:19 (4:1 in English Bibles), JPS 1917, with the Name written YHVH
“And ye shall tread down the wicked; for they shall be ashes under the soles of your feet in the day that I do make, Saith YHVH of hosts.”
Malachi 3:21 (4:3 in English Bibles), JPS 1917, with the Name written YHVH
Stubble. Neither root nor branch. Ashes. That is an end, not an endless life in pain. Two verses are often used the other way, so read them honestly. Daniel says some will awake “to reproaches and everlasting abhorrence” (Daniel 12:2, JPS 1917). Isaiah describes the righteous going out to look “Upon the carcasses of the men that have rebelled against Me; For their worm shall not die, Neither shall their fire be quenched; And they shall be an abhorring unto all flesh” (Isaiah 66:24, JPS 1917). Those are carcasses, dead bodies, and the abhorrence is the shame others feel looking at them. The fire is not quenched until it has done its work. Nothing in either verse is a living soul in torment.
Yeshua taught the same. He warned of Gehenna, the valley of Hinnom outside Jerusalem, where children had once been burned to Molech (Jeremiah 7:31–32), a place of destruction:
“And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.”
Matthew 10:28, KJV (the Greek word is Gehenna)
Destroy. Not preserve forever. Paul wrote, “the wages of sin is death” (Romans 6:23, KJV). Death, not eternal life in fire.
Where the torment came from
The Greek world taught that the soul is immortal by nature. Plato argued it at length in the Phaedo, and in the Gorgias (525c) and the Republic (book 10, the myth of Er) he described punishments for the wicked after death, some of them without end. Greek myth had already filled its underworld, Hades and Tartarus, with sinners punished forever: Tantalus reaching for fruit he could never touch, Sisyphus rolling his stone. When church teachers trained in Greek philosophy read the Apostolic Writings, they read an immortal soul into them, and a soul that can never die must be put somewhere forever.
This is the same thing that happened with the Logos. Philo of Alexandria dressed the Hebrew Scriptures in Greek philosophy, and later teachers used his Logos to make a second divine being out of a man. (See Philo in His Own Words.) The immortal soul and the Logos are both philosophy laid on top of Scripture.
Then, around 1300, the Italian poet Dante Alighieri wrote the Inferno. He built hell in nine circles, each with its own punishments, and over its gate he wrote:
“Dinanzi a me non fuor cose create / se non etterne, e io etterno duro. / Lasciate ogne speranza, voi ch’intrate. (Before me nothing was created except eternal things, and I endure eternally. Abandon every hope, you who enter.)”
Dante, Inferno 3.7–9, NCAY translation
Dante’s pictures shaped how the Western church imagined hell for seven hundred years, in sermons, paintings and books. But Dante was a poet, writing his own vision, with Greek and Roman figures from myth placed among the damned. He was not a prophet of YHVH.
Why this matters
A Creator who keeps billions alive in fire forever is not the Father the prophets knew. He says, “Have I any pleasure at all that the wicked should die? saith YHVH; and not rather that he should return from his ways, and live?” (Ezekiel 18:23, JPS 1917, with the Name written YHVH). He offers life. Those who refuse it come to an end. That is justice and mercy together. It is comforting to learn, because it is true.
Sources
- Scripture: The Holy Scriptures (Jewish Publication Society, 1917) and the King James Version, both public domain, with the Name written YHVH and “God” meaning Him written “the Eternal.”
- Dante Alighieri, Inferno, canto 3, lines 7–9 (Italian text).
- Plato, Phaedo; Gorgias 523a–527a; Republic 10.614b–621d.
- Homer, Odyssey 11 (Tantalus and Sisyphus in the underworld).
