Something From Nothing? Newton, the Fertile Egg, and the Missing Link Evolution Cannot Find
They teach our children that everything came from nothing, by accident, and then built itself. Cry aloud and spare not: it did not. The heavens, the zebra, the rattlesnake and the egg on your table all point back to one Cause who planned them. The men who laid the foundations of modern science said so in their own words. We will let them speak.
“In the beginning the Eternal created the heaven and the earth.”
Genesis 1:1, JPS 1917, “God” written “the Eternal” per NCAY practice
“By the word of YHVH were the heavens made; And all the host of them by the breath of His mouth. … For He spoke, and it was; He commanded, and it stood.”
Psalm 33:6, 9, JPS 1917, with the Name written YHVH
The spiritual missing link: something from nothing
Everyone agrees on one rule: nothing comes from nothing. The ancient materialists knew it. The Roman poet Lucretius built his whole system on it, saying that nothing is ever brought into being out of nothing by divine power (On the Nature of Things 1.149–150, paraphrased). His answer was to make matter itself eternal. If matter always existed, no Creator is needed to start it.
That is the dodge. Science itself has since given up the idea of an eternal, unchanging universe; the mainstream picture today is a universe with a beginning. A beginning needs a Beginner. The “missing link” the evolutionists never found is not a bone in the ground. It is the step from nothing to something, and from dead matter to life. Matter cannot take that step by itself.
René Descartes, the French philosopher and mathematician, called the rule an eternal truth:
“When we apprehend that it is impossible a thing can arise from nothing, this proposition, EX NIHILO NIHIL FIT, is not considered as somewhat existing, or as the mode of a thing, but as an eternal truth having its seat in our mind, and is called a common notion or axiom.”
Descartes, Principles of Philosophy I.49 (1644), trans. John Veitch
And he went further. The world does not only need a Cause to begin; it needs a Cause to keep it in being every moment:
“…from the fact that we now are, it does not necessarily follow that we shall be a moment afterwards, unless some cause, viz., that which first produced us, shall, as it were, continually reproduce us, that is, conserve us. For we easily understand that there is no power in us by which we can conserve ourselves, and that the being who has so much power as to conserve us out of himself, must also by so much the greater reason conserve himself, or rather stand in need of being conserved by no one whatever, and, in fine, be God.”
Descartes, Principles of Philosophy I.21 (1644), trans. John Veitch
“For it is clear to anyone who considers the nature of time that the very same power and action are needed to conserve a thing at each moment it lasts as would be needed to create it anew if it did not yet exist; so that conservation differs from creation only in the way we think of it.”
Descartes, Meditations on First Philosophy, Meditation III (1641). NCAY’s translation from the Latin: “eadem plane vi, et actione opus esse ad rem quamlibet singulis momentis quibus durat conservandam, qua opus esset ad eandem de novo creandam…”
Isaac Newton in his own words
Newton did not leave the question of origins to others. He answered it, again and again, and he answered it against chance. People sometimes credit him with the phrase “the invisible hand”; that phrase belongs to the economist Adam Smith (1776). Newton’s own words go further: he names a Cause that is intelligent, powerful and wise, and he says blind chance could never have done the work.
In 1692 the young preacher Richard Bentley asked him whether his system of the world supported belief in the Creator. Newton wrote back:
“When I wrote my treatise about our Systeme I had an eye upon such Principles as might work with considering men for the beleife of a Deity & nothing can rejoyce me more then to find it usefull for that purpose.”
Newton to Bentley, 10 December 1692, Trinity College Cambridge 189.R.4.47, Newton Project
“…I do not think explicable by mere natural causes but am forced to ascribe it to the counsel & contrivance of a voluntary Agent.”
Same letter, on why the Sun alone shines while the planets do not
“To your second Query I answer that the motions which the Planets now have could not spring from any naturall cause alone but were imprest by an intelligent Agent. … This must have been the effect of Counsel. … To make this systeme therefore with all its motions, required a Cause which understood & compared together the quantities of matter in the several bodies of the Sun & Planets & the gravitating powers resulting from thence … And to compare & adjust all these things together in so great a variety of bodies argues that cause to be not blind & fortuitous, but very well skilled in Mechanicks & Geometry.”
Same letter
“…they seem to make up that harmony in the systeme which (as I explained above) was the effect of choice rather then of chance.”
Same letter
A few weeks later he wrote again, on gravity itself:
“Tis unconceivable that inanimate brute matter should (without the mediation of something else which is not material) operate upon & affect other matter without mutual contact … Gravity must be caused by an agent acting constantly according to certain laws, but whether this agent be material or immaterial is a question I have left to the consideration of my readers.”
Newton’s fourth letter to Bentley (February 1693), Trinity College Cambridge 189.R.4.47, ff. 7–8, Newton Project
In 1713 he added the General Scholium to the second edition of his Principia, the book that gave the world the laws of motion and gravity:
“This most beautiful system of the sun, planets, and comets, could only proceed from the counsel and dominion of an intelligent and powerful Being.”
Newton, Principia, General Scholium (1713), trans. Andrew Motte (1729), 1846 American edition
“…it is not to be conceived that mere mechanical causes could give birth to so many regular motions…”
Same
“Blind metaphysical necessity, which is certainly the same always and every where, could produce no variety of things. All that diversity of natural things which we find suited to different times and places could arise from nothing but the ideas and will of a Being necessarily existing.”
Same
Then in his Opticks he took the argument from the sky down to living bodies, the very ground the evolutionists claim. Read it slowly:
“All these things being consider’d, it seems probable to me, that God in the Beginning form’d Matter in solid, massy, hard, impenetrable, moveable Particles, of such Sizes and Figures, and with such other Properties, and in such Proportion to Space, as most conduced to the End for which he form’d them …”
Newton, Opticks, Query 31 (4th ed., 1730)
“…it’s unphilosophical to seek for any other Origin of the World, or to pretend that it might arise out of a Chaos by the mere Laws of Nature; though being once form’d, it may continue by those Laws for many Ages. For while Comets move in very excentrick Orbs in all manner of Positions, blind Fate could never make all the Planets move one and the same way in Orbs concentrick … Such a wonderful Uniformity in the Planetary System must be allowed the Effect of Choice. And so must the Uniformity in the Bodies of Animals, they having generally a right and a left side shaped alike, and on either side of their Bodies two Legs behind, and either two Arms, or two Legs, or two Wings before upon their Shoulders, and between their Shoulders a Neck running down into a Back-bone, and a Head upon it; and in the Head two Ears, two Eyes, a Nose, a Mouth, and a Tongue, alike situated. Also the first Contrivance of those very artificial Parts of Animals, the Eyes, Ears, Brain, Muscles, Heart, Lungs, Midriff, Glands, Larynx, Hands, Wings, swimming Bladders, natural Spectacles, and other Organs of Sense and Motion; and the Instinct of Brutes and Insects, can be the effect of nothing else than the Wisdom and Skill of a powerful ever-living Agent…”
Newton, Opticks, Query 31 (4th ed., 1730)
“…the main Business of natural Philosophy is to argue from Phaenomena without feigning Hypotheses, and to deduce Causes from Effects, till we come to the very first Cause, which certainly is not mechanical…”
Newton, Opticks, Query 28 (4th ed., 1730)
“Out of a Chaos by the mere Laws of Nature.” That is the theory of evolution, a hundred and thirty years before Darwin, and Newton called it unphilosophical. Eyes, ears, brain, heart, lungs, wings and instinct: he named them one by one and said they could be the effect of nothing else than a wise, ever-living Agent. The laws of nature run things once they are made. Traced backward, they do not make themselves. They point to a Lawgiver. NCAY calls Him by His Name: YHVH, Yehovah.
Even Darwin felt it: the eye
“To suppose that the eye, with all its inimitable contrivances for adjusting the focus to different distances, for admitting different amounts of light, and for the correction of spherical and chromatic aberration, could have been formed by natural selection, seems, I freely confess, absurd in the highest possible degree.”
Charles Darwin, On the Origin of Species (1st ed., 1859), chapter 6
To be fair to him, Darwin went on to argue that it could still happen by countless small steps. We quote him whole, not twisted. But mark what he admitted: on its face, the eye looks designed. Newton looked at the same eye and believed what he saw.
The rattlesnake: Darwin’s own test
Go back to the first edition of Darwin’s book, the one printed in 1859, and read him in his own words. He set his own test for the whole theory:
“If it could be proved that any part of the structure of any one species had been formed for the exclusive good of another species, it would annihilate my theory, for such could not have been produced through natural selection. Although many statements may be found in works on natural history to this effect, I cannot find even one which seems to me of any weight. It is admitted that the rattlesnake has a poison-fang for its own defence and for the destruction of its prey; but some authors suppose that at the same time this snake is furnished with a rattle for its own injury, namely, to warn its prey to escape. I would almost as soon believe that the cat curls the end of its tail when preparing to spring, in order to warn the doomed mouse. But I have not space here to enter on this and other such cases. Natural selection will never produce in a being anything injurious to itself, for natural selection acts solely by and for the good of each.”
Charles Darwin, On the Origin of Species, 1st ed. (London: John Murray, 1859), chapter 6
He named the rattlesnake himself. He brushed it off with a joke about a cat, and then: “I have not space here.” Now compare the sixth edition of 1872, the last one he revised:
“…but some authors suppose that at the same time it is furnished with a rattle for its own injury, namely, to warn its prey. I would almost as soon believe that the cat curls the end of its tail when preparing to spring, in order to warn the doomed mouse. It is a much more probable view that the rattlesnake uses its rattle, the cobra expands its frill and the puff-adder swells while hissing so loudly and harshly, in order to alarm the many birds and beasts which are known to attack even the most venomous species. Snakes act on the same principle which makes the hen ruffle her feathers and expand her wings when a dog approaches her chickens.”
Darwin, On the Origin of Species, 6th ed. (London: John Murray, 1872), chapter 6
Mark the changes. “To warn its prey to escape” became “to warn its prey.” “I have not space here” was dropped, and in its place came an explanation: the rattle scares off enemies. The test he set, “it would annihilate my theory,” stayed in the book. The hard case was given a story.
But think it through. If all of life is only a blind struggle to survive, why does a killer carry a warning bell? A rattle tells every bird, every rabbit and every man exactly where the snake is. And why the dry bite? Rattlesnakes often strike in defense without injecting venom at all. Doctors and snake researchers know this well: a share of defensive bites to people are “dry,” and studies of pit vipers find the snakes can meter how much venom they release. A machine built only to survive should not hesitate. It should not warn, and it should not hold back. The rattlesnake warns, and it holds back. That is restraint, and restraint is not a product of blind chance.
And the parts still come as a set: venom glands, the muscles that squeeze them, hollow fangs that fold back and swing forward to strike, heat-sensing pits to find warm prey in the dark, and the rattle itself, a stack of loose, interlocking rings of keratin with a new ring added at each shed, shaken by tail muscles that can buzz it dozens of times a second. Venom without fangs is useless. Fangs without venom are useless. Half a rattle makes no sound.
The zebra: how did it live before the stripes?
No two zebras have the same stripes. After more than a century, scientists still argue over what they are for: hiding from lions, confusing biting flies, cooling the body, or helping the herd know one another. Field studies with horses dressed in striped coats have found that biting flies have trouble landing on stripes. So ask the plain question: if the stripes are what keep the zebra alive, how did it live before it had them? And if it lived fine without them, they were not needed to survive, and survival did not make them.
The same question goes for every living thing. The heart needs the lungs, the lungs need the blood, the blood needs the heart. The eye is useless without the nerve, and the nerve is useless without the brain to read it. The bee needs the flower and the flower needs the bee. How did each creature live while it waited for the parts it needed to live? It could not. Each one had to be complete from its first day, “after its kind,” just as Scripture says.
Which came first, the chicken or the egg?
The egg cannot come first. It has to be a fertile egg: it needs a hen to form it and a rooster to fertilize it. The shell itself is made inside the hen, and in 2010 researchers in England reported that a protein made in the hen’s ovaries, called ovocleidin-17, helps build the shell. No hen, no shell. No rooster, no chick. Scripture puts the creature first, made complete and able to reproduce:
“And the Eternal created the great sea-monsters, and every living creature that creepeth, wherewith the waters swarmed, after its kind, and every winged fowl after its kind; and the Eternal saw that it was good. And the Eternal blessed them, saying: ‘Be fruitful, and multiply, and fill the waters in the seas, and let fowl multiply in the earth.’”
Genesis 1:21–22, JPS 1917, “God” written “the Eternal” per NCAY practice
The mathematics of chance
They say time and chance can do anything. Put numbers on it.
A protein is a chain of amino acids, and there are 20 kinds to choose from at each link. A modest chain of 150 links can be arranged in 20150 ways, about 10195. Only a tiny fraction of those fold into anything that works. In 2004 the molecular biologist Douglas Axe published an experimental estimate in the Journal of Molecular Biology that roughly 1 in 1077 such sequences would form a working enzyme fold. Other scientists dispute his figure, but even far kinder numbers leave the same problem. For scale, the number of atoms in the whole visible universe is usually estimated at about 1080. And one protein is not life. The simplest living cell needs hundreds of them working together, plus the code to build them and the machinery to read the code.
The astronomer Sir Fred Hoyle, no friend of the Bible, worked the odds himself. In his 1983 book The Intelligent Universe he compared (in paraphrase) the chance origin of life to a tornado sweeping through a junkyard and assembling a Boeing 747 from the parts. (Hoyle’s own conclusion leaned toward an intelligence, though not toward the Creator of Scripture.)
Then go backward. Every effect has a cause, and every cause before it has a cause. If the chain went back forever, to infinity, it would never have arrived at today, because an endless line of steps can never be finished. You cannot cross infinity to get here. But today is here. So the chain has a beginning: a first Cause that was not caused by anything else. That is exactly where Newton said science must end up: “till we come to the very first Cause, which certainly is not mechanical.” Philosophy tried to escape this by saying matter always existed. That is only infinity again, and it explains nothing. The first Cause is not matter and not chance. He is YHVH.
What they kept quiet about Newton
Most people know Newton as a scientist and nothing more. Very few know that he wrote more about Scripture than about science, or that he rejected the Trinity. That was no accident. His science was printed and praised. His theology was put in boxes.
Newton believed in one God, the Father. In his private Twelve Articles on religion he wrote:
“There is one God the Father everliving, omnipresent, omniscient, almighty, the maker of heaven & earth, & one Mediator between God & Man the Man Christ Iesus.”
Newton, Twelve Articles on religion, Keynes Ms. 8, King’s College Cambridge, Newton Project
“The father is the invisible God whom no eye hath seen or can see, all other beings are sometimes visible.”
Same, article 2
Here is the record of what happened to those papers:
- 1690: Newton sent John Locke his study of two verses he believed had been corrupted to support the Trinity (1 John 5:7 and 1 Timothy 3:16). He did not publish it. It was first printed in 1754, long after his death, and not under his own direction.
- 1779–1785: Bishop Samuel Horsley, an Anglican, published what was called Newton’s complete works. By the Newton Project’s account it was “extremely conservative” and mostly reprinted what was already public. The theology stayed in the family’s boxes.
- 1855: David Brewster, Newton’s great Victorian biographer, had seen the papers, yet, in the Newton Project’s words, “perversely claimed that Newton’s theological views were not unorthodox.”
- 1872–1888: The Earl of Portsmouth gave the scientific papers to Cambridge University. The committee kept the science. The papers catalogued as chronology, history and theology were sent back to the family estate at Hurstbourne. The catalogue appeared in 1888.
- 1936: The family sold the papers at Sotheby’s in London on 13 and 14 July. The economist John Maynard Keynes bought mostly the alchemical papers. The Jewish scholar Abraham Shalom Yahuda gathered the theological papers, drawn, as the Newton Project puts it, by “the comparatively low status accorded to Christ in Newton’s version of Christianity.”
- 1951 onward: After Yahuda’s death his collection went to what is now the National Library of Israel in Jerusalem. It became generally open to scholars only at the end of the 1960s.
- 2012: The National Library of Israel put the theological manuscripts online, with the Newton Project. For the first time, anyone could read them.
So who kept it quiet? Not one church alone. The men who held the papers for two hundred years were Protestant: an Anglican bishop, a Victorian biographer, a university committee. The theologians of every camp had the same choice. They could share Newton’s science and his proof of a Creator, and let his one-God faith come along with it, or share the science alone. For two centuries they chose the science alone. The Creator Newton saw was kept in the textbooks only as far as it was safe. The one God Newton worshipped was kept in a box.
Know Him by His Name
“For thus saith YHVH that created the heavens, He is the Eternal; That formed the earth and made it, He established it, He created it not to be empty or chaotic, He established it to be settled and inhabited: I am YHVH, and there is none else.”
Isaiah 45:18, JPS 1917, names per NCAY practice
Not chaos. Not chance. Not matter that always was. He formed the earth to be inhabited, and He gave us His Name. The wisest men of science looked at the heavens and at living bodies and confessed an intelligent Cause. We know His Name: YHVH. Call on Him.
Sources
- Scripture: The Holy Scriptures (Jewish Publication Society, 1917), public domain, with the Name written YHVH and “God” meaning Him written “the Eternal.”
- Isaac Newton to Richard Bentley, 10 December 1692 and February 1693, Trinity College Library, Cambridge, 189.R.4.47; transcriptions at the Newton Project.
- Isaac Newton, Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy, General Scholium (1713), trans. Andrew Motte (1729), American edition 1846.
- Isaac Newton, Opticks, 4th ed. (London, 1730), Queries 28 and 31.
- Isaac Newton, Twelve Articles on religion, Keynes Ms. 8, King’s College, Cambridge (Newton Project).
- René Descartes, Principles of Philosophy I.21 and I.49 (1644), trans. John Veitch; Meditationes de prima philosophia, Meditation III (1641), Latin text.
- Lucretius, De rerum natura 1.149–150.
- Charles Darwin, On the Origin of Species, 1st ed. (1859) and 6th ed. (1872), chapter 6 (texts at Project Gutenberg, nos. 1228 and 2009; also Darwin Online and archive.org).
- D. D. Axe, “Estimating the prevalence of protein sequences adopting functional enzyme folds,” Journal of Molecular Biology 341 (2004): 1295–1315.
- Fred Hoyle, The Intelligent Universe (1983).
- Adam Smith, The Wealth of Nations (1776), book IV, chapter 2 (“invisible hand”).
- The Newton Project, “History of Newton’s Papers”: “1727–1872,” “The Portsmouth Papers,” “The Sotheby Sale.” National Library of Israel, “Newton Manuscripts.”
- T. Caro et al., “The benefits of zebra stripes: behaviour of tabanid flies around zebras and horses,” PLoS ONE (2019).
- C. L. Freeman et al., “Structural control of crystal nuclei by an eggshell protein,” Angewandte Chemie (2010), on ovocleidin-17.
