What Sir Isaac Newton Really Believed, in His Own Words
Search and study
A funnel in the brain will take whatever is poured into it. Search and study will not. Christian authors have long told the public that Sir Isaac Newton was an orthodox Trinitarian, a loyal son of the Church of England’s creed. His own manuscripts say otherwise. You do not have to take a biographer’s word for it. You can read him yourself.
The claim, and why it matters
Newton is still put forward as proof that a brilliant mind can rest in the Trinity. The picture is familiar: he went to chapel, he wrote of God in the Principia, and later church writers folded him into orthodox faith. That picture does not survive contact with the papers he left behind.
Those papers are not hidden in a vault. The Newton Project at Oxford has put them online. What follows is taken from his own hand, with links. Spelling is lightly modernized from the Project’s normalized transcriptions so the words are easy to read. The meaning is his.
The Father alone is the one supreme God
In a short paper now called the “Twelve articles on religion,” Newton wrote his faith in plain sentences. It is Keynes Ms. 8, King’s College, Cambridge.
“There is one God the Father everliving, omnipresent, omniscient, almighty, the maker of heaven and earth, and one Mediator between God and Man the Man Christ Jesus.”
Isaac Newton, Twelve articles on religion, Artic. 1. Keynes Ms. 8. Newton Project
He closed the same paper with the same line of Scripture he loved, 1 Corinthians 8:6, and then he told you what he meant by it:
“To us there is but one God the Father of whom are all things and we of him, and one Lord Jesus Christ by whom are all things and we by him. That is, we are to worship the Father alone as God Almighty and Jesus alone as the Lord the Messiah the great King the Lamb of God who was slain and hath redeemed us with his blood and made us kings and Priests.”
Newton, Twelve articles, Artic. 12. Keynes Ms. 8. Newton Project
That is not a Trinity of co-equal persons. The Father alone is worshipped as the Almighty. Newton honours the Son as Messiah, King and Lamb — not as a second God beside the Father.
A distinct, subordinate Son
In his Irenicum, or Ecclesiastical Polyty tending to Peace (Keynes Ms. 3), Newton said the same thing in creed form. We are to believe in one God, the Father, “almighty in dominion, the maker of heaven and earth,” and in Jesus Christ, the son of God, born of a virgin, sacrificed, raised, and seated at the Father’s right hand,
“being next unto him in honour and power.”
Newton, Irenicum. Keynes Ms. 3. Newton Project
Next unto him is not equal with him. In the same Twelve articles he wrote, “The Father hath life in himself and hath given the son to have life in himself,” and “Christ came not to diminish the worship of his Father.” Prayer, he said, is to be directed to the Father in the name of the Son. That is the line of Yeshua’s own words: “Why do you call me good? No one is good but One, that is, the Eternal.” Mark 10:18 (NKJV, names per NCAY practice). Yeshua worshipped Yehovah, and he did not ask to be seated as a co-equal God.
He called the Trinity a fourth-century corruption
Newton did not treat the Trinity as a mystery handed down from the apostles. He treated it as a later insertion. In his drafts on the history of the Church (Yahuda Ms. 15, National Library of Israel), he compared the early creeds and marked the later clauses in brackets — “God of God, light of light, very God of very God … consubstantial to the Father.” Then he said this:
“In these two creeds, the articles which are contained within the brackets were inserted in the fourth century, and if they be omitted, the creeds agree with one another and with the creed set down by Irenaeus, and by their agreement confirm one another to be the true universal tradition of faith during the three first centuries.”
Newton, Drafts on the history of the Church. Yahuda Ms. 15.5. Newton Project
In the same papers he argued that the Nicene language of a “consubstantial” Son sat easily with fourth-century converts who were used to heathen gods of one substance with a supreme God. Whether every step of that history persuades you or not, his conclusion is not in doubt: the faith of the first centuries was belief in one God, the Father, and in His Son — not the later creed.
He showed that two Trinity proof-texts had been altered
In 1690 Newton wrote a long letter to John Locke, later titled An Historical Account of Two Notable Corruptions of Scripture. He took apart 1 John 5:7, the so-called Johannine Comma (“the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost, and these three are one”), and 1 Timothy 3:16. Both had been used as pillars of the Trinity. He judged that the wording was changed in the fourth or fifth century. He would not let the faith lean on a forged verse:
“In the eastern nations, and for a long time in the western, the faith subsisted without this text, and it is rather a danger to religion than an advantage to make it now lean upon a bruised reed. There cannot be better service done to the truth than to purge it of things spurious.”
Newton, An Historical Account of Two Notable Corruptions of Scripture (1690). Newton Project
He did not publish that letter in his lifetime. It appeared only in 1754, twenty-seven years after he died. The Newton Project’s catalogue calls it “a crucial document for the study of Newton’s theology, in particular his anti-Trinitarianism.” Catalogue, THEM00099.
Why he hid it
This was not a hobby he was shy about. Denial of the Trinity was illegal in England in his lifetime. Michael Servetus had been burned at Geneva in 1553, in part for the same denial. Newton was Lucasian Professor, then Warden and Master of the Mint, and President of the Royal Society. He had a great deal to lose. So he conformed in public, and he wrote the truth in private.
Stephen Snobelen, who has spent years in these papers, calls Newton a “Nicodemite”: a man who held a faith his church would have judged heresy, and who never made a public declaration of it. See Snobelen, “Isaac Newton, heretic: the strategies of a Nicodemite,” British Journal for the History of Science 32 (1999): 381–419. Cambridge Core. Rob Iliffe, director of the Newton Project and author of Priest of Nature: The Religious Worlds of Isaac Newton (Oxford, 2017), writes that Newton concluded “the orthodox notion of the Trinity was a fiction that was invented in the early fourth century,” and that “Jesus was divine but was not God.” Newton’s Religious Life and Work.
Be fair to him, and to the record
Some writers still point to Newton’s church attendance, or to the word “God” in his public science, and call him an orthodox Trinitarian. Others argue over the label: was he strictly an Arian, or something close to it but his own? Fair enough. Scholars may debate the exact school. They do not get to debate the sentences he wrote. Those sentences are not the Athanasian Creed. They are not the Thirty-Nine Articles on the Trinity. They say the Father alone is the one supreme God, and that the Son is a distinct, subordinate son, next to Him in honour and power.
Be fair to Newton in the other direction as well. He wrote in the language of his day — God, Jesus, Christ — and he honoured the Son as Messiah and mediator. He was not writing a modern NCAY essay. He also did not write the creed later authors have pinned on him. We write Yehovah when we speak of the Father, and we write YHVH in Scripture quotes. His manuscripts already point to the same throne: the Father alone.
Do not take the funnel
The habit of the age is to pour a story into the mind and call it settled. Newton would not have it. He searched the manuscripts, compared the creeds, and tested the verses. “There cannot be better service done to the truth than to purge it of things spurious.” Search and study is not optional. It is how the truth stays the truth.
Read him for yourself. Start here:
- Twelve articles on religion (Keynes Ms. 8): newtonproject.ox.ac.uk/view/texts/normalized/THEM00008
- Irenicum (Keynes Ms. 3): newtonproject.ox.ac.uk/view/texts/normalized/THEM00003
- Drafts on the history of the Church (Yahuda Ms. 15.5): newtonproject.ox.ac.uk/view/texts/normalized/THEM00222
- Two Notable Corruptions of Scripture: newtonproject.ox.ac.uk/view/texts/normalized/THEM00261 and catalogue THEM00099
Sources
- Isaac Newton, “Twelve articles on religion,” Keynes Ms. 8, King’s College, Cambridge. Newton Project: THEM00008.
- Isaac Newton, “Irenicum, or Ecclesiastical Polyty tending to Peace,” Keynes Ms. 3, King’s College, Cambridge. Newton Project: THEM00003.
- Isaac Newton, Drafts on the history of the Church, Yahuda Ms. 15.5, National Library of Israel, Jerusalem. Newton Project: THEM00222.
- Isaac Newton, An Historical Account of Two Notable Corruptions of Scripture (letter to John Locke, 1690; first published 1754). Newton Project: THEM00261; catalogue: THEM00099.
- Robert Iliffe, “Newton’s Religious Life and Work,” Newton Project, 2013. newtonproject.ox.ac.uk/view/contexts/CNTX00001. See also Rob Iliffe, Priest of Nature: The Religious Worlds of Isaac Newton (Oxford University Press, 2017).
- Stephen D. Snobelen, “Isaac Newton, heretic: the strategies of a Nicodemite,” British Journal for the History of Science 32 (1999): 381–419. Cambridge Core.
- Scripture quotation: Mark 10:18, New King James Version, with “God” for the Father written “the Eternal” per NCAY practice. In our own words we say Yehovah when we speak of the Father.
