A close photograph of many red roses
|

We Do Not Keep Valentine’s Day — and Here Is Why

Holidays

NCAY INC does not keep Valentine’s Day. Faithful love between a husband and a wife is honorable. A mid-February festival of Cupid, cards, and a poorly attested saint is not a commandment of YHVH, and we will not keep it as if it were.

What can be said with care

Valentine’s Day is observed on February 14. Encyclopaedia Britannica records that it did not come to be celebrated as a day of romance until about the fourteenth century. The day took its name from one or more Christian martyrs called Valentine, commemorated on that date. The historical accounts of those men are thin. The 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica noted that the passions attached to the Roman priest and the bishop of Terni have no secure foundation, and that the association of a lovers’ festival with St. Valentine “seems to be purely accidental.” In 1969 the Catholic Church removed the feast of St. Valentine from the General Roman Calendar because so little about him could be historically established, while still listing him in the Roman Martyrology.

The earliest clear literary link between St. Valentine’s Day and the choosing of mates is often traced to Geoffrey Chaucer’s Parliament of Fowls (commonly dated to the early 1380s), which speaks of birds choosing mates on that day. Later European courts and, much later, printers and merchants turned the date into a traffic of verses, gifts, and, in time, a commercial cult of romance.

A popular claim ties Valentine’s Day directly to Lupercalia, a mid-February Roman festival of purification and fertility that included rites later writers described as wild and sexual. Pope Gelasius I opposed Lupercalia at the end of the fifth century. Some have said he replaced it with St. Valentine’s Day. Serious historical notes, including a Princeton index essay on the holiday, warn that there is no firm evidence that Lupercalia simply became Valentine’s Day. We will not lean on a link the evidence does not secure. We will say this, and we will say it plainly: Lupercalia was a pagan rite in the same season; Cupid is the Roman god of desire; and the modern holiday still trades on romance detached from the covenant of YHVH. That is enough to refuse the day.

What it stands for—and why we will not keep it

Scripture honors marriage and faithful love. It does not honor the worship of desire as a god, or a holy day invented for a saint the records barely know. “Thou shalt have no other gods before me.” Exodus 20:3 (KJV). We will not give a feast day to Cupid, and we will not treat a church-calendar leftover as if it came from Sinai.

If a husband and wife give thanks for one another, they need no February 14 to do it. They need the instruction of YHVH, and a life that keeps it.

Sources

  • Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Valentine’s Day.”
  • Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), “Valentine,” via the University of Chicago’s Penelope edition of the 1911 text.
  • Princeton University Art Museum Index, “Happy Valentine’s Day!” (2016), on Chaucer and the lack of firm evidence linking the day to Lupercalia.
  • Geoffrey Chaucer, The Parliament of Fowls.
  • Associated Press, “Origins of Valentine’s Day are murky.”
  • Exodus 20:3.

Similar Posts